Last week we had a woman come and give several lectures to our department about behavior analysis and autism. She helps run a large treatment center in Georgia for children with autism.
The two lectures she gave in the morning were pretty interesting. In the afternoon, we had a handful of presentations so that some of my fellow graduate students could share their current research projects. This was great fun because it resulted in a lot of good discussion and conversation.
One fun thing about graduate school is that I get to interact with and learn from people who are involved in areas of behavior analysis that are pretty different from what I do. It’s fascinating to get to see different perspectives and approaches to teaching and training. At the end of the day, though, what I’m often left realizing is that good training is good training, no matter what species you work with or what task you are trying to train.
One thing that the speaker mentioned in one of her morning lectures was that when teaching a particular behavior, we should focus on training only one thing at a time. During a training session, only work on improving one aspect or feature of a behavior at a time.
Animal trainers often get in to trouble here! For instance, when teaching an animal to stay, work on increasing the duration of the behavior separately from increasing the distance between you and the animal. Don’t try to train both of these at once! This can be confusing to the animal and can slow down our training. When training, try to do what animal trainers refer to as a splitting, rather than lumping. (What is splitting?)
Taking lots of short breaks during a training session can make it a lot easier to be a good splitter. This is one thing I’ve learned from horse clicker trainer Alexandra Kurland. I often train in short sessions, 10-20 treats. At the beginning of the session, I decide what we’re going to work on during that session. Then, when I run out of treats, I take a short break before the next session. During the break I decide whether to work again on the same thing or whether we’re ready to move on. If the last session didn’t go so well, I might decide to move to something easier or different, so that the animal can be successful and understand what I want.
I think the take home message from all of this is that it helps to have a well thought out plan before you begin each training session. When we are trying to train too much at once, it is often because we haven’t thoroughly assessed where the animal is currently and what exactly, specifically, we want to work on in the current training session.
Can you work on more than one thing but just not at the same time? Like if you do want to work on more than one thing on a particular day… say targeting and backing up on cue you should make them two separate sessions with a break in between?
Thanks for the comment. Great question.
I think it depends partially on where the animal is in his or her training and how well the animal knows the behavior.
When I’m shaping a new behaviors, I almost always work on that behavior by itself. Or, if I do add in other behaviors, I only add in behaviors that the animal knows really well. So, I might be teaching a horse to back, but also throw in some targeting repetitions to help keep the rate of reinforcement high.
If the horse knew zero about targeting or backing, I probably wouldn’t combine those in the same session. But, if the animal was really clicker savvy, I think many trainers are able to work on improving behavior 1 and improving behavior 2 in the same session.
So, in short, it can depend.
I just try to make sure that in any one short session, I pick one thing to focus on and click for. Actually saying it or writing it down can really help. So, for example, maybe for these 15 treats the horse and I are going to work on having him back up with a slightly lower headset. That’s something really concrete that I can click for. And then, I’m not also looking at speed of backing, number of steps backing, ear position, and all the other things I could be clicking for while the horse is backing.
I think that’s where it starts getting confusing and frustrating for both the human and the horse—when we don’t have clear criteria and we end up sometimes clicking for one aspect of the behavior, sometimes for another aspect of the same behavior, and sometimes clicking for a totally different behavior. Hope that clarified the post a bit.
~Mary
This picture you have uploaded is too good. The topic is very interesting.
Really dogs are very faithful….its my real experience.I am very impressed with your views and interesting content. I hope you intend to continue writing more informational articles.
Thanks for sharing this nice post here,keep it up.
Yep, I’m horrible about lumping. It’s something I have to work on all the time lol. Must split, must split, must split. Maybe that should be my mantra hehe.
Thanks for this useful information.
Really i am impressed from this post. The person who created this post is a genius and knows how to keep the readers connected. Thank you for sharing this with us. I found it informative and interesting. Looking forward for more updates.